Some Challenging Questions (2) — Lesson 19

Elders: Household Limits, Marriage Questions, and the Leadership Crisis
Thesis: God’s qualifications for elders are both firm and merciful. They are firm because the flock must be protected. They are merciful because God does not require perfection—He requires proven faithfulness, stability, and spiritual maturity. Some cases are settled by direct Scripture. Other cases demand wise judgment by the local church, because the local church must live with the outcome.

Question 1 — Is a Man Automatically Disqualified as an Elder by Adult Unfaithful Children?

Two key texts must be kept together: “having children who believe, not accused of dissipation or rebellion” (Titus 1:6) and “one who manages his own household well… (but if a man does not know how to manage his own household, how will he take care of the church of God?)” (1 Timothy 3:4–5).

The controlling phrase: “his own household”

Paul ties the qualification to a man’s ability to rule what is actually his to rule—his household. God built adulthood on separation and accountability (Genesis 2:24). When a child establishes their own home, they are no longer under the father’s authority.

What the local church must not do

The church must not turn this into a superstition: “If an adult child falls away, the father must have failed.” The Bible teaches personal accountability (Romans 14:12; Galatians 6:5; Ezekiel 18:20). A parent cannot override free will.

What Scripture does allow the church to consider

  1. The father may have ruled harshly: If the home was managed through intimidation rather than dignity (Ephesians 6:4).
  2. Public conduct and reputation: If adult children live nearby and bring constant scandal, destroying the man’s influence locally (1 Timothy 3:7).

Bottom line answer: No, a man is not automatically disqualified. But the local church must evaluate his true fatherhood and present influence.

Question 2 — Is an Elder Automatically Disqualified When His Wife Dies?

The text says the elder must be the husband of one wife (1 Timothy 3:2; Titus 1:6). It does not say “must have been married once.”

Why this requirement is wise

A faithful wife provides essential strength: balance under criticism, insight into people, and stability when decisions are attacked. God’s requirements are not random.

Bottom line answer: Widowhood raises a real Scriptural issue. The local church must handle it with firmness and compassion, never twisting Scripture nor endangering the flock.

Question 3 — Does a Man With One Child Meet the Qualification of Having “Children”?

The issue is not quantity, but 家庭领导 (Household Leadership). Scripture uses the plural “children” to speak of offspring generally.

  • Sarah: Spoke of “children” though she had one son (Genesis 21:7).
  • Levirate Law: Fulfilled by one son (Matthew 22:24; Deuteronomy 25:5–6).
  • Commandments: No father is exempt from commands regarding “children” if he has only one (Ephesians 6:4).

Bottom line answer: Yes. The church must evaluate the home leadership demonstrated, not family size.

Question 4 — Lawful Divorce, Remarriage, and Qualification

The requirement is “the husband of one wife.” This means he must be lawfully married and devoted to one wife in God’s sight. He must not be bound to a former covenant while living in another.

Scripture’s rules for lawful remarriage

Death (1 Corinthians 7:39) or divorce for the ground of sexual immorality (Matthew 19:9) permits marrying another. If his present marriage is lawful before God, he is not living in adultery.

Bottom line answer: If a man is lawfully married in God’s sight, he is not disqualified simply because he has been married previously. We must not add “married only once in his lifetime” to the text.

The Leadership Crisis

Churches collapse slowly when leadership dries up. Leadership is formed in the home, starting when boys are at the kitchen table. They must be taught respect for truth and how to lead without pride. We also need fearless, grounded women. Titus 2:3–5 shows that women shape the entire church by training the next generation. The church must prepare leadership from the cradle (Deuteronomy 6:6–7; 2 Timothy 2:2).

Teaching Slides — Lesson 19

Slide 1: Household Rule and Adulthood
The BoundaryThe Biblical LogicKey Texts
Limit of AuthorityElders must rule “their own household.”1 Tim. 3:4
AdulthoodChildren leave and establish new households.Gen. 2:24
AccountabilityEvery soul answers for their own choice.Ezek. 18:20
Slide 2: “Children” as Offspring
Bible ExampleText ContextPattern
Sarah (Gen 21:7)“Sarah would nurse children”Refers to Isaac alone.
Fathers (Eph 6:4)“Do not provoke children”Applies even to one child.
Widows (1 Tim 5:4)“If any widow has children”Indicates general offspring.
Slide 3: Lawful Remarriage and Elders
The StandardCommon ErrorThe Reality
“Husband of one wife”“Married only once in a lifetime”Text uses present-tense state.
Matt. 19:9 / 1 Cor 7:39Adding rules God didn’t writeLawful marriage is not sin.
Focus on FidelityTechnicalities over characterMust be a “one-woman man.”
© EVV Keeping the Faith Ed Rangel
Scroll to Top